dr lisa kane

Lisa Kane “Motorized” normal_
I can’t read “Non Motorized” without thinking “Non White” and “Non European”. Then I’m left wondering what the consequences are of South Africans adopting the term “NMT” (Non Motorized Transport)?

  “Non Motorized”, like “Non European”, makes one category normal and the other abnormal. With ‘normality’ and ‘abnormality’ come the baggage of acceptability (or not), being the centre of attention (or not) and (more practically) institutional resources (or not). Are we comfortable to make motorized movement normality, and other ways of moving about the abnormal?

  The current vocabulary, like the practices, have been largely adopted from elsewhere. “Non Motorized Transport” is a peculiarly North American term not widely used in less auto-focused Europe. There the talk is more of “walking and cycling”.

  “Active transport” has been adopted by those with an anti-obesity agenda for transport, while “slow modes” works well for the slow food and slow life movements. “Accessible transport”, meanwhile, carries the longings of those frustrated by car culture. “Micro-mobility” has been more recently adopted to account for e-bikes and scooters, but it doesn’t capture feet.

  None of these evoke the richness of things-which-move-without-petrol-motors-in-South-Africa and for good reason. Informal traders needing to navigate streets are barely heard of in Boston. Children walking to school en masse along rural highways are not a widespread feature of Dutch life. Needing to navigate the sprawling Apartheid city without an income does not have the same pressing urgency in New York. The places which have birthed and deeply informed our traffic engineering vocabulary and our ways of designing and planning the South African city do not share our cultures.

  South Africans are adept at inventing vocabulary for uniquely South African matters. 

South-African-things-that-move-under-their-own-steam (rather than petrol or coal energy) deserve something more ambitiously home-grown than the regressive and imported label “Non-motorized”.